Carbon One Safe Reviews: CarbonOne Safe Advises Owners to Keep Certified CO Alarms in Place This Winter
Company says its plug-in monitor is not yet UL listed and should be used only alongside a certified CO alarm
Press Release Disclaimer: This is a press release distributed through the XPR Media network. It has not been independently verified by our newsroom.

![]()

Company says its plug-in monitor is not yet UL listed and should be used only alongside a certified CO alarm
NORTH CANTON, Ohio, November 20, 2026 — CarbonOne Safe today disclosed that its CarbonOne Safe Detector, a plug-in monitor for carbon monoxide, natural gas and propane, does not hold a published finished-product listing under UL 2034, the U.S. safety standard for residential carbon monoxide alarms, or UL 1484, the standard for residential gas detectors. In a heating-season advisory for the 2026–27 winter, the company advised households not to use the device as their carbon monoxide alarm and to keep a UL 2034-listed alarm installed on every level of the home and outside sleeping areas.
The advisory draws a line between two kinds of device. A UL 2034-listed alarm has been tested by an independent laboratory to sound at set carbon monoxide levels within set times. The CarbonOne Safe has not completed that testing, so its display and alarm are intended as a supplementary source of information placed next to a listed alarm, not as a substitute for one.
“Heating season is when people start thinking about carbon monoxide, and they deserve a straight answer about what a detector has and hasn’t been tested to,” said Henry Lame, Communications Manager at Onninest, which operates CarbonOne Safe. “Until a listing is published for our device, households should keep a certified alarm on every level and treat our display as an extra layer of information.”
The CarbonOne Safe Detector plugs into a standard wall outlet, includes battery backup and shows a live carbon monoxide reading in parts per million (ppm). The company said it will publish the testing laboratory, standard and file number if and when the finished device is listed.
What the advisory covers
The company’s advisory has four parts.
-
Certification status. As of November 20, 2026, no UL 2034 or UL 1484 listing has been published for the finished CarbonOne Safe Detector. The device does not hold UL 217 smoke alarm certification and is not described as a smoke alarm.
-
Supplementary use. Until a listing is published, the company advises that the device be used alongside a UL 2034-listed carbon monoxide alarm and working smoke alarms. Existing required alarms should not be removed, relocated or disabled.
-
Specification disclosure. The company has separated the specifications it publishes as design features from those that an independent laboratory has not verified.
-
Placement and response guidance. The company has published placement and emergency-response guidance drawn from the U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission (CPSC), the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) and the National Fire Protection Association (NFPA).
Why the listing matters in winter
Carbon monoxide is a gas with no color, smell or taste. It is produced whenever fuel is burned, including in furnaces, water heaters, gas ranges, fireplaces, cars and portable generators. According to the CDC, more than 400 Americans die each year from unintentional carbon monoxide poisoning not linked to fires, more than 100,000 visit an emergency department and more than 14,000 are hospitalized.
The CDC notes that early symptoms are often mistaken for the flu, and that people who are asleep can be overcome before they notice anything. For that reason, the practical warning in a home is an alarm rather than a person’s senses.
Exposure tends to rise in colder months, when heating equipment runs for long periods, windows stay closed and portable generators come into use during winter power outages. The CPSC issues warnings each winter about carbon monoxide and fire hazards linked to furnaces, space heaters, fireplaces and generators.
Those conditions are why the company chose the start of the heating season to state its certification status. A household that replaced a listed alarm with an unlisted monitor would be relying on a device whose alarm points have not been checked against the national standard during the months when that standard matters most.
What UL 2034 and UL 1484 require
Home carbon monoxide alarms in the United States are tested to UL 2034, a standard developed with input from the CPSC. The CPSC advises consumers to install a CO alarm that meets the current UL 2034 standard and notes that an alarm is no substitute for proper use and upkeep of fuel-burning appliances.
UL 2034 sets alarm points by both concentration and time. A listed alarm must sound within 60 to 240 minutes at 70 ppm, within 10 to 50 minutes at 150 ppm and within 4 to 15 minutes at 400 ppm. It must not alarm at a steady 30 ppm, a rule meant to prevent false alarms from brief background levels, such as those near a gas stove. The time-weighted design reflects how carbon monoxide builds up in the blood: a brief exposure at a moderate level affects the body less than a longer one.
Detectors for natural gas and propane are tested to a separate standard, UL 1484. The NFPA’s NFPA 715 standard sets out where residential fuel gas alarms should be installed, and the NFPA notes that fuel gas alarms must be tested and labeled by a recognized third-party laboratory.
The CarbonOne Safe has not been tested against either standard. Its alarm thresholds for carbon monoxide and fuel gas have therefore not been independently confirmed.
How households can check any detector
The company published the following steps so buyers can check the status of any carbon monoxide or gas detector, including its own.
Look for the laboratory mark and the standard. A listed carbon monoxide alarm carries the mark of a nationally recognized testing laboratory, such as UL or Intertek (ETL), and names UL 2034 on the device or packaging. A listed gas detector names UL 1484. A listed smoke alarm names UL 217.
Look up the listing. UL Solutions maintains a free public database, Product iQ, where listings can be searched by company name, model number or file number. Intertek maintains a similar directory for ETL-listed products.
Match the model. A listing applies to a specific finished model. A certified component, such as a sensor, does not make the finished device certified.
Read the wording closely. Phrases such as “certified sensor technology” or “professional-grade” describe parts or marketing positioning, not a listing of the finished alarm.
“A listing is a fact anyone can look up in a few minutes,” Lame said. “We would rather people check our status in a public database than take our word for it, and the same goes for any other detector in their home.”
Verification status of published specifications
The company lists the following details for the CarbonOne Safe Detector and states which have been independently verified.
-
Gases monitored: carbon monoxide, natural gas and propane, according to the company. Not verified by a testing laboratory.
-
Smoke detection: not claimed. The device holds no UL 217 listing.
-
Carbon monoxide sensor: electrochemical. This describes the component type only; the finished device is not listed.
-
Natural gas and propane sensor: sensor type not yet published.
-
Display: live carbon monoxide reading in ppm starting from 0 ppm. Display accuracy has not been independently tested.
-
Carbon monoxide alarm thresholds: not yet published and not tested against UL 2034.
-
Fuel gas alarm level: not yet published and not tested against UL 1484.
-
Alarm volume: decibel rating not yet published.
-
Power: plug-in with battery backup. Backup run time, automatic switchover and low-battery signaling have not yet been published.
-
Self-test: automatic, according to the company. A self-test checks circuitry and does not confirm sensor accuracy.
-
Rated service life: five years, a company rating.
Until the unpublished figures are tested by an independent laboratory, the device’s performance against UL 2034 and UL 1484 is not established.

What a live reading adds, and what it does not
The CarbonOne Safe shows a live carbon monoxide reading starting from 0 ppm, so a household can see low levels that would not trigger a UL 2034 alarm. Low-level monitors of this kind have been studied. A 2022 comparison of four low-level carbon monoxide alarms, published in Undersea and Hyperbaric Medicine, found that all four devices alerted at levels well below the UL 2034 alarm points. The paper also notes that at least one manufacturer describes its low-level device as a monitor that does not replace a UL 2034 alarm where one is required.
A reading depends on sensor performance, calibration, placement and temperature. A low or zero reading should never override an audible alarm from another device, symptoms of possible exposure or any other sign of an emergency. A reading that rises above zero and stays there is a reason to ventilate the home, leave if anyone feels unwell and have fuel-burning appliances checked by a technician.
“The number on the screen is useful, but it is information, not a guarantee,” Lame said. “The listed alarm is the device that wakes you up.”
More Deatils about CarbonOne Safe on their official website.
Placement guidance from the CPSC and NFPA
Carbon monoxide. The CPSC advises installing carbon monoxide alarms with battery backup on every level of the home and outside sleeping areas, ideally interconnected so that when one sounds, they all sound. Carbon monoxide alarms may be plugged into an outlet or mounted high on a wall. They should not be placed near heating vents or where furniture or curtains can cover them.
Natural gas and propane. Placement depends on the gas. Natural gas is lighter than air and rises, while propane is heavier than air and settles. For that reason, manufacturer instructions for fuel gas alarms typically call for natural gas alarms high on a wall and propane alarms near the floor. A wall outlet near the floor suits propane detection but sits far from where natural gas collects. Households that use natural gas should follow the installation instructions for height and should not use an extension cord to raise a plug-in unit.
Smoke. The CPSC advises smoke alarms on every level of the home, outside sleeping areas and inside each bedroom. The CarbonOne Safe is not a smoke alarm and does not replace them.
Outlets to avoid. Outlets controlled by a wall switch, outlets behind furniture or curtains, and outlets beside kitchen ranges, bathrooms or heating vents can affect a plug-in detector’s readings or cause it to lose power. The company advises confirming that the chosen outlet is always live.
Where carbon monoxide comes from in a home
Most household carbon monoxide comes from fuel-burning equipment that is not working or venting properly. Common sources include furnaces and boilers with cracked heat exchangers or blocked flues; gas water heaters and clothes dryers with poor venting; gas ranges and ovens used for heating; fireplaces and wood stoves with blocked chimneys; attached garages where a running car can push exhaust indoors; and portable generators, grills and camp stoves used indoors, in garages or near windows.
The CDC’s prevention advice centers on these sources. Heating systems, water heaters and other gas-, oil- or coal-burning appliances should be serviced by a qualified technician every year. Generators, pressure washers and gasoline engines should never run inside a home, basement or garage, or less than 20 feet from a window or door. Gas ovens should never be used to heat a home, and cars should never be left running in an attached garage, even with the door open.
“Most of the work happens before an alarm ever has a reason to sound,” Lame said. “An annual furnace inspection does more for a household than any detector, ours included.”
Maintaining any detector
The CPSC advises testing smoke and carbon monoxide alarms monthly and replacing batteries at least once a year, unless the alarm uses a sealed long-life battery. Vents on plug-in and wall-mounted units should be kept clear of dust. Aerosol sprays, paint, solvents and household cleaners should not be used directly on or near a detector, since their vapors can affect gas sensors.
Carbon monoxide sensors wear out over time, which is why alarms carry a rated service life, typically five to 10 years depending on the model. The manufacture or replacement date printed on each unit should be checked once a year, and any alarm past its rated life should be replaced even if it still appears to work.
If any alarm sounds
The CPSC and CDC give the same core steps when a carbon monoxide alarm sounds: everyone, including pets, should leave the home for fresh air; 911 or the local fire department should be called from outside; no one should go back inside until emergency responders say it is safe; and fuel-burning appliances should be inspected by a qualified technician before they are used again.
For a suspected natural gas or propane leak, occupants should leave immediately, avoid switching lights or appliances on or off, and call the gas utility or 911 from outside. The company says these steps apply whichever device sounds.
Limitations stated by the company
CarbonOne Safe says its detector is a supplementary monitor, not a certified carbon monoxide alarm. It does not stop carbon monoxide or gas from being produced, and it does not replace annual servicing of fuel-burning appliances, smoke alarms, UL 2034-listed carbon monoxide alarms, or safe outdoor use of generators and grills. Placement affects how quickly any detector responds, and a single unit cannot cover a whole home. The company does not claim that the display can diagnose any health condition.
Next steps
The company said it will update its published certification status when testing of the finished device is complete, including the laboratory, standard and file number of any listing. Its current certification status, installation instructions and safety guidance are published on the official CarbonOne Safe website.
About CarbonOne Safe
CarbonOne Safe is a home-safety product line owned and operated by Onninest, a U.S. direct-to-consumer home products company based in North Canton, Ohio, and founded in 2020. Onninest develops and sells household products online under several brand names, including CarbonOne Safe for carbon monoxide and fuel gas monitoring and Pest Vault for plant-based rodent deterrence. Each brand operates its own product website, while customer service, fulfillment and returns are handled centrally by Onninest. This release was issued by the Onninest communications team on behalf of CarbonOne Safe.
Media Contact
Henry Lame
Communications Manager, Onninest (CarbonOne Safe)
1-888-814-2188
7233 Freedom Ave NW, North Canton, OH 44720
References
U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, “Carbon Monoxide (CO) Poisoning Basics.”
U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission, “Carbon Monoxide Fact Sheet.”
U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission, “CO Alarms.”
U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission, “There’s a Chill in the Air – Stay Warm Safely,” 2025.
U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission, “Carbon Monoxide Alarm Conformance Testing to UL 2034.”
National Fire Protection Association, “Staying Safer from Natural Gas and Propane Leaks and Explosions,” February 2025.
Hampson NB. “Comparison of four low-level carbon monoxide alarms suitable for home use.” Undersea and Hyperbaric Medicine, 2022.
UL Solutions, “Product Sourcing and Certifications Database (Product iQ).”
